Carmine's Pizzeria Italiano - Niagara Falls, Ontario

Liliana Q. R.

Carmine’s Pizzeria Italiano is hands down my favorite spot for pizza. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with the warm, welcoming aroma of freshly baked dough and flavorful toppings. It’s not just about the food here—it’s the complete experience. The staff are always friendly, attentive, and ready to make you feel right at home. Their customer service truly stands out, adding a personal touch to every visit.

Let’s talk about the pizza: it’s simply the best. The crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and soft, the sauce is rich and tangy, and the toppings are always fresh and generously applied. Every bite is bursting with flavor, making it clear why this place is so beloved.

And it’s not just about pizza! Their wings are a must-try. Perfectly cooked with a delicious variety of sauces to choose from, they’re the kind of wings you dream about coming back for. Pair them with your pizza, and you’ve got the ultimate comfort meal.

One of the best parts about Carmine’s is how family-friendly it is. My kids are notoriously picky eaters, yet even they love the pizza here! It’s a rare and wonderful thing to find a place where everyone in the family is excited to eat. Knowing that there’s something for everyone—and that my kids will actually finish their meals—is a huge win for me.

On top of all this, the prices are incredibly reasonable for the quality of food you get. Whether you’re feeding a family, grabbing a quick meal, or ordering for a party, Carmine’s offers great value. It’s clear that they care about their customers and take pride in delivering fantastic food without breaking the bank.

Overall, Carmine’s Pizzeria Italiano is a gem. Between their unbeatable pizza, delicious wings, friendly service, and kid-approved menu, it’s no surprise they’ve become my go-to spot. If you’re looking for a place that consistently delivers amazing food and an excellent experience, Carmine’s is the place to be!

john F.

Was well surprised by ghe pizza I have been going to different places lately and never like the pizza carmine's was great
Thin crust not over loaded with cheese and just the right amount of toppings I realky enjoyed it and will be going back and the price is great 20 bucks gor a large zaaa can't go wrong pizza and wing prices are good too ill try that next time
Sorry ate the pizza before taking a Pic lol

Think I'm gonna try the chicken parm sub next time
Like I said tried the chicken parm, was great a little less sauce for me but hey that's just taste my wifes steak sub was amazing. And she told me i will l be ordering more again

Vhirtue-

Called and ordered at 2:30, arrived on time, was told pizza would take another hour and 15, absolutely embarrassing for an establishment that has been in business for a while. Lady on the phone showed that you guys cannot handle a large amount of customers and your greed caused multiple familes to go without dinner for your chance at another dollar. Will not be returning alongside other patrons. Please respond professionally. Customers appreciate the service that is paid for. And taking to many orders that you cannot handle is quite terrible business practice.

Matthew E.

Definitely a great pizza. A slab is $20 (plus tax) for 1 topping. Sauce has a nice flavour profile with a hint of sweetness. Cheese is good quality and crust has a nice crunch. Crust has a nice golden colour and was cooked perfectly. Staff are friendly and in a good location. Everytime we go here the food just keeps getting better and better. The wings are amazing with a copious amount of sauce.

Geri B.

Carmine's has the best pizza around...period!!! Their dough and crust is just the right thickness, not too thick, not too thin. Cheese is tasty, not greasy. Pepperoni is always great and their homemade sauce is delicious, with always the right amount. This is the only pizza place where I don't have to ask for extra sauce or to have it well done. It's always cooked perfectly.
The best part is that it is actually owned by Carmine! He's a very nice man, and his staff is awesome too. Since I started going there, I don't go anywhere else for pizza. Try them and you'll be hooked, guaranteed.

R

The lady that answered the phone was very clear and pleasant, I appreciate that. 🙏 I didn't have to repeat myself.
Now the pizza was fkn awesome, cooked perfectly, and had a great amount of toppings. My kid is not crazy about pizza but told me it was really good.
I'm not a person to get wings for takeaway, but I did. The Cajun dry rub wings are amazing. There were no leftovers 🥲
Do yourself a favor and try Carmine's pizza. Your tastebuds will thank you.
Thanks, Carmines, for a great supper that the family enjoyed, I will definitely be a repeat customer.

Shawn

We’ve been ordering from carmines for a few years now but this is the second time since they moved to their new home. The pizza is even better than before. Nice crisp to the bottom of the crust and the wings were perfectly saucy and good size.

Harvey J. M.

For almost 2 years, my friends occasionally order here for pizza and wings. They say it always hits the spot and affordable. 😊

And they were right!

My last order (which was a while ago) was one of the best-looking pizzas I've seen and ate. Even my relatives finished a whole box within seconds. I should have ordered more boxes at that time 🤣

Kudos to the staff and owner.